I'm sorry, but I just can't see how BU could be picked 2nd in the Valley next year...even in the most kool-aid saturated moments.All of this is 'on paper', which is all we have to go by right now.
SIU should be down a bit. They are losing the preseason POY and another top forward in Shaw. Mullins is great defensively, but is very limited offensively. We saw this year how important experience is, especially with interior players. SIU will contend for a top half finish, but I wouldn't pick them above 4th or 5th.
Drake loses quite a bit too. I think they'll have enough to be a top 5-6 team, but I wouldn't underestimate the value of Emmenecker, Houston, and Corver.
If I had to make a preseason prediction based on returning players, it would go like this
1. CU
2. BU
3. ISU
4. DU
5. SIU
6. INSU
7. WSU
8. UNI
9. MSU
10. UE
I can elaborate if necessary, but I think if you look on paper with what each school has returning, BU has an advantage over most of the league outside of CU.
Unless something that BU has returning "on paper" magically figures out how to play solid team defense, all the offensive talent we may have coming back in TW, SM, AW, etc. is not going to mean a thing...We are already counting heavily on a red shirt freshman to "anchor the middle" for us and at last check I believe he was 6'10" and 185 lbs...and as much as I like Warren, Maniscalco, and Wilson, I don't think any of them are going to be mentioned as all-Valley defensive team members any time in their careers.
I think we will finish better than where we are picked...but I think we will be picked 5th or 6th in the conference in the pre-season...and that is about right. CU, ISU, and Drake should be picked ahead of us...I know Drake loses a lot, but they still have Josh Young and Cox and a system there that seems to work...SIU will likely be picked ahead of us...Mullins, Bone, Clemmons, Boyle, Fay, and an unparalleled recruiting class isn't a flawless group, but it will give them a chance to be good...then I think it is between us and Indy State for the 5th spot...
I wish I shared your optimistic assessment of 2nd for BU...but I have to look beyond just the offensive numbers of the BU returnees when I'm trying to get a feel for where they should finish next year...and I just don't see them being a good defensive team next year...maybe Dunson and whoever the last scholarship goes to can bring in some much needed defensive presence...we'll see.