It’s not exactly about spots 12-13. It’s about always getting the best possible players. By the way, I’m sure spots 9-13 love Calipari basically saying they’re no good haha.
There are so many talented players left that could push the guys in the top 8 or 9. Are Atlason, Davis, and Burch so good they cannot be pushed for spots 6-8? Or how about Linke/Meta/Johnson (whichever is in spot 9)?
Are we so sure Dillon will be a D1 star that he can be in penned in? Thomas too? Etc, Etc. Is this roster really more talented than the pretty good but flawed and depth lacking roster last year? If not, keep trying to make it better. As we saw last year it only takes one injury to derail a season when Hickman was out (fortunately only a few weeks). What if we have multiple injuries or guys don’t work out like we hoped?
Meta has a long way to go if he ever gets there. Linke is a nice backup big, but isn’t a starter. Biliew didn’t play at all last year. Hardtke was a walk-on severely limited in what he can do on the court. That’s three of the scholarships right there (Linke has to be a walk-on). So now we’re down to 10 guys right off the bat. Johnson and van der Knaap might have a huge adjustment period as freshmen, especially coming from the leagues they did. Now we’re down to 8 reliable guys already at the start. That’s leaves us zero margin for error. That was the same problem we had last year and it cost us at times, why voluntarily do that again when Biliew had graduated and moved on? We fulfilled our commitment to him and gifted Hardtke a scholarship for a semester last year due to guys leaving. It’s not like we would have been yanking the scholarships. Are we really that afraid to ruin the culture that we just don’t try to get the best talent?
And if every team is really only rostering 8 talented players as Calipari suggests, there should be plenty of talented guys looking for a roster spots and to compete. Plus talent pushes other younger talent to get better, example: Hannah facing Mast in practice daily. As upper class men who have kind of shown their talent ceiling, I don’t have a ton of hope Meta or Linke are pushing Hannah/Thomas in the same way even if they play with effort.
Remember last year when people thought we were 11 deep and how quickly that evaporated? This year we’re starting 8-9 deep voluntarily.